Picture this: You’re a Mumbai-based startup owner, like Arjun, who poured heart and soul into optimizing his e-commerce site for Google search. After months of tweaking SEO, his traffic was steady—until Google rolled out AI Overviews in May 2024. Suddenly, impressions held strong, but clicks plummeted.
Google claims AI enhances search, promising more engagement. Yet, Arjun wondered: Is this true, or just clever marketing? With ScreenTime Digital by his side, he uncovered the real story through his data. Let’s walk through Arjun’s journey and learn how you can separate hype from truth in this AI-driven 2025 landscape.
Arjun’s Eye-Opening Discovery
Arjun noticed his top product pages still ranked high, but fewer visitors clicked through. Buzz on social media hinted at a shift—marketers on X were whispering about AI Overviews stealing clicks, with some reporting drops of up to 50%.
Skeptical of Google’s rosy claims, Arjun turned to ScreenTime Digital’s ****SEO + Performance Tracking. Comparing data before and after May 2024, he found CTR on long-tail queries like “best eco-friendly shoes” had dipped by 30%, even as impressions remained stable. This wasn’t a penalty—it was a sign users found answers in AI summaries instead of his site.
The Truth Behind Google’s Claims
Google boasts that AI Overviews keep users engaged longer, but they’re light on proof. Arjun learned the hard way that impressions don’t equal action. Posts on X suggest a growing sentiment: AI might boost visibility, yet it often ends search journeys without clicks.
For startups like Arjun’s, this means rethinking success metrics. ScreenTime helped him see that trusting Google’s narrative blindly could hide the real impact on his business.
– Related read: Search Engine Journal: AI Search Results Impact
Unpacking the Data with ScreenTime Digital
Arjun’s journey revealed key insights, powered by ScreenTime’s expertise. Here’s how you can follow his lead:
1. Tracking the CTR Drop with SEO + Performance Tracking
Arjun checked top queries in Google Search Console, focusing on question-style searches like “how to choose sustainable footwear”. With ScreenTime’s guidance, he compared CTR before and after AI Overviews.
The result? A clear dip, signaling that AI was answering queries before users reached his site. This insight helped Arjun build a data-backed content adjustment plan.
2. Measuring “Quality Clicks” with GA4 + Advanced Analytics Setup
Google hinted at fewer bounces, but Arjun wanted proof. ScreenTime’s GA4 setup helped him track:
Engaged sessions (10+ sec with conversions or multi-page views)
Average engagement time
Scroll depth
This data confirmed that though clicks were fewer, engagement quality remained strong. If these metrics drop, you may be attracting the wrong audience.
3. Diversifying Content with Content Strategy + Multimedia SEO
Arjun noticed AI favored authentic formats like Reddit threads and YouTube videos. ScreenTime helped him:
Add how-to videos
Embed podcast snippets
Result: A 25% click boost on video content. Static blogs lagged behind. He aligned with what AI surfaces and users want.
4. Adapting to Traffic Shifts with AI Content Optimization
Quick-answer pages were losing steam. ScreenTime used Search Behavior Analysis to show:
Product reviews were being outranked by Reddit discussions
Users preferred in-depth expert guides
Arjun adapted, shifting toward thought-leader content that made him more AI-citable.
Real-World Buzz and Examples
X users report an average 34.5% CTR drop since AI Overviews
Brands like Amazon adjust for AI citations, seeing 35% of revenue come through smart optimization
– Source: TechCrunch AI CTR Analysis
Arjun’s pivot with ScreenTime matched this trend, showing startups can not only survive but thrive in the AI era.
Overcoming the Hype with Data
Adapting wasn’t easy. Arjun feared losing ground, but ScreenTime’s analytics framework ensured he stayed aligned with evolving search behavior. This clarity helped turn disruption into opportunity.
Take Control of Your Future
Don’t let AI clicks cloud your growth. Like Arjun, you can master this shift with ScreenTime Digital’s services.
Subscribe to our newsletter for weekly updates
Let your data guide your decisions—because in 2025, real impact beats vague promises.
A Startup’s Journey to Email Success
Let’s work together to create a performance-driven marketing system for your brand. Share your project details and we’ll send you a custom quote within 24 hours.
